In my book, one of the essays I was most satisfied with, and received the most feedback for, is entitled "Blue Flax Dance," a piece that explores the many letting-gos a woman must live through, comparing the life of a married woman/mother to the life cycle of the blue flax flowers that bloom wild all summer in meadows, barrow pits and flower beds throughout the West. In "Blue Flax," I write of a watching a married couple circle the dance floor on Saturday night when I'd had a fight with Shawn and ended up at the bar. I talk of how graceful the woman was as she followed her husband's lead, "swirling, turning, dancing backwards with elegance and grace." To appear so graceful on the floor, the woman had to let go of the will to control the dance, and move backwards to her husband's moves, in order to propel the dance forwards.
I did that for nearly 30 years - danced backwards to keep my marriage intact, my family together. The woman in the rose-colored dancing dress might have been blessed enough to have a husband who fully supported and cherished her, so that she could relax in his arms, trusting his vision to guide them across the floor, confident in his strength to protect her and keep her from falling.
I did not.
Written between the lines of "Blue Flax" is the story of a woman constantly moving from ranch to ranch because of a husband whose perennial dissatisfaction led to a constant search for a "perfect" job. The fight we'd had the night before I'd driven wildly to the bar? Earlier that evening, he'd told me he had given his two weeks' notice at the ranch where we'd lived for five years; although we'd discussed him quitting, he actually resigned without telling me. He'd also rented a house in town before I'd even had a chance to view it. The new job he'd accepted, the house he'd rented? He thought both of those things were "what's best for our family." Whether the new house and job, leaving the ranch at Ucross, were good or bad for our family is beside the point. The point is that he made that decision alone, without listening to my voice. Leadership of the dance, our family, taken, not given. Definitely not earned.
And yet, when I, justifiably, got angry and left the house, I allowed a chance encounter with a married woman dancing in a small town bar to convince me to just go back home. I even wrote that digging in my heels, refusing to leave - as if I had a choice - would make me a "bitch."
I look back now at that label and in that one seemingly small word lies the crushing weight of patriarchy, the absolute devaluing of woman's power. Language can be used a s a weapon, and in my relationship with Shawn, it was the instrument of choice. Often the words used were innocent-sounding enough.... just like his justification that he wanted "what's best" for our family earlier that day. Using terms like those allows a gaslighter, a manipulator, to take the upper hand in a conversation, because any further argument against his point would be, by default, a fight against "what's best." To argue against "what's best" would make me the selfish one, the one who didn't care about our family. Insinuations of my selfishness made up the current I swam against daily, the current I drowned in most of the time.
Sometimes, the abuse was more blatant, the weapons more sharply pointed - labeling me "bitch" or "cunt' any time I did stand up to the manipulation, raise my face out of the current long enough to out-argue and out-reason him. When he knew he couldn't win by any other means - short of physical abuse - Shawn hurled words so hurtful that I stopped speaking just to make them stop. Interestingly, the fact that he "never laid a hand" on me was a source of pride to Shawn.
But in order for the verbal abuse to work, in order for those words to have an effect on my decisions, my own brain had to cooperate. I had to buy into the illusion that a good mom only wants "what's best" for her family - never what's best for her. Forget any idea that what is best for a mom could actually be the highest good for her children as well - that idea was not even a consideration My worth was based on my ability to let go, to sacrifice - like generations of "good" moms before me. The woman labeled by men as "bitches," "cunts," "ball-breakers," and "nasty women" - these were the selfish ones, the dark witches who ate children and danced naked in the forest. We didn't talk about those ones. We strove never to be one of those women. We were "good" girls.
In truth, the woman on the dance floor didn't convince me to go back home, to Shawn, that night: my culture did. The culture that told me, growing up, that only "good" girls got to heaven. The culture that taught me to take care of others, to put my needs second, to blend into the wallpaper and not call attention to myself, my needs. The culture that ignored my adventuresome recklessness and my deep intelligence but praised my cookie-baking and jelly-canning skills, and told me I'd "make someone a good wife someday." The culture that raised me to view having a man as the ultimate proof of my worth, to view other women as competition for a limited number of men on the planet, to feel triumph when a man - regardless of his own value as a human being - "chose" me over another girl. The culture that whispered about the shame of divorces and the tragedy of single motherhood. The culture that marveled at my supposed abilities to raise six babies, commenting on what a "good" mom I was.
The depth of the horseshit in these beliefs suffocates me. Looking back now at that night, over sixteen years ago, and knowing in hindsight what was to come for my babies, I will tell you what a "good" mom would have done.
A good mom would have packed those six babies into that oversized SUV before speeding down the highway, and she wouldn't have stopped at a goddamn bar. She would have swallowed her pride, let go of the need for her family's approval, and she would have driven all the way to the South Dakota farm where she and her babies were safe, would have told the truth, would have asked for help. She would have let go of the belief that she could handle it all, that she was somehow still in control. She would have surrendered to the dance, accepted the signs that had already started blazing, and put to death any idea of being a perfect wife and mother.
A good mom would not have allowed her babies to grow up thinking such an imbalance of power was natural in a marriage. She would not have allowed her precious, beautiful daughters to learn that grace and worth came from dancing backwards, from dropping pieces of their identities, the way the blue flax drops it petals, in order to earn a man's approval. She would not a have allowed her sweet, handsome son to grow up thinking that simply being male entitled him to special treatment. Mostly, she would have allowed her children to see her for all she was, not just the parts that were socially accepted and approved of. She'd have let them see the beauty of her breaking down and falling apart, instead of the false, filtered, carefully-kept-together version she usually presented.
And yet, as angry as I am now at the woman who went back home that night, I have compassion for her as well. She was 34 years old. My oldest daughter just turned 27 - only 7 years' difference. That 34-year-old woman simply made the best choice she could have at the moment. She believed she was doing the right thing, and until that belief changed, she was not capable of leaving. So she survived. Like the blue flax, she adapted to her tough environment by letting go of things.... but not the things I originally wrote about. Sure, that woman let go of her body, her beauty, her own personal dreams. But she let go of so much more.
When the blue flax drops its petals, it appears as dead as any other flower past its bloom. In truth, I had been dying, slowly, for many years before that full-moon night. A petal dropped when Shawn first told me to fuck off, the night before our wedding, when he was so blindly drunk he couldn't stand up. A petal dropped the next day, when he found me and apologized, so tearful, so contrite, and I smiled my way through the ceremony and laughed as he got drunk again at the reception. A petal dropped when his parents came to visit shortly after our wedding, and his mother cried that he wouldn't sit with her anymore, so he left me alone on the love seat and went to sit with her on the couch. A petal dropped when he arrived at the hospital where my dad lay dying, and couldn't wait to get to the hotel to have sex to "make me feel better." A petal dropped when Laura, our oldest, was delivered by c-section, and he became angry at the prospect of not having sex for eight weeks, and then lamented that I didn't seem to have time for him now that the baby was here.
So many years. So many petals. So much dying. The fights over leaving various ranches, various homes, my jobs almost always sacrificed for his. My bouts with loneliness and depression when the moves and the isolation became too much, and his frustration at why I couldn't "just be happy." The texts, phone calls, and pictures from strange women, or sometimes women I actually knew, who were "just friends" or "just clients." The criticism of our kids, that they were too loud, too messy, too spoiled, too overweight, too ... whatever, and that somehow it was my job to fix them. The endless dissatisfaction, with jobs, with meals, with weekend plans, with me. The silent treatments, hours and days without speaking to me, often without explanation, broken usually with fiery, intense bouts of sex that left me confused and uneasy, though I didn't understand why. And always, above all, the words - sometimes innocent-sounding, sometimes blatantly disrespectful, but always having the effect of making me choose between the uneasy feeling in my gut and the nagging voice in my head that told me to "just go home."
But I didn't know where home was. I thought home would be the life I had created, the wife and mother of six, the hard-working, resourceful woman who could manage a huge family, a huge home, and a husband with a huge ego. I'd been brought up to believe that God only gives us as much as we can handle, and so I didn't question that He seemed to think I could handle a lot. I simply disassociated from myself. I learned to work twelve to sixteen hour days, to be mind-numbingly productive, to fill every waking moment with a project or errand, to prove my worth my what I accomplished. After all, that's what the women in my family had done for generations. I learned to anticipate Shawn's moods, and to intercept bad behavior, difficult news, and minor inconveniences such as my monthly cycle, all in order to prevent his outbursts. I became not just a control freak, but a control monster. I bought into the myth - planted in my mind since childhood - that if I just did enough, accomplished enough, brought home enough, supported enough, he would finally approve of me, finally love me, finally see me. The way that woman on the dance floor seemed to be seen by her husband.
Over the years, after that full-moon night, that 34-year-old woman - who grew to be 51-year-old me - let go of more than her dignity. She let go of being a stay-at-home mom, to return to work twice - once as a teacher, and once, after yet-another move to yet-another ranch, as a public librarian. And that letting go of the idea of being a stay-at-home mom, that forcing herself out of the isolation her husband would have liked to keep her in, led to a career, a masters' degree, and a workplace of women with healthy - or at least healthier - marriages. Where the woman in the rose-colored dress convinced me to return to Shawn and his various infidelities, the women at my library job showed me that marriage could be more than a continual backwards dance with a partner whose moves were dangerously predictable. I began to see that having a man who loves you has less to do with who you are as a woman, and more to do with who that man is himself. Some men are not capable of love.
Not that the letting go became any easier for me. In the spring of 2019, I was forced to let go of that which I'd literally sacrificed everything for - my marriage and even two of my kids. In moves that followed a classic narcissistic discard, Shawn started a relationship with another woman while still living and sleeping with me, and then asked for a divorce when that woman promised to divorce her own husband. What followed, the months that followed, were the darkest I've experienced in my life. The things I've since learned about Shawn - about the multiple infidelities going back at least to the time I was pregnant with Emily, if not before; about the smear campaign he began with our children long before he discarded me; about the web of lies and false images he kept in place to protect him from being seen for who he truly was; about the actions - such as attempting to slice the tires of a hired man who quit him - that he blamed on me; about the threats and insults he used on our children to demoralize and control them - these have threatened to destroy me, have come close to convincing me that my life is no longer worth living. The tears, the crushing ache, the obsessive thoughts, the overwhelming guilt, and the wretchedness of that period were unlike anything I've ever had to survive.
And yet, I did survive. Or more accurately, I am surviving; each day is a new battle. I survived the way I survived the emotional abuse for nearly 30 years. I cooked, I cleaned, I gardened. I sobbed, I screamed, I prayed. I threw my time and attention to creating a home and caring for my kids. Sometimes I escaped into books, but I also used books and information to fertilize the growing knowledge within me, the knowledge that the abuse I suffered was not my fault.... it reflected a poison within the man I had married, but not a defect in me.
And I am gradually letting go, again. I am now letting go of those ideas from childhood that a woman's worth comes from keeping a man, a marriage, a family. I'm letting go of the conditioning of my church, that somehow married life is holier, counts for more, than single, divorced life. I'm letting go of the idea that a man, any man, should be able to determine my value, and I'm facing the dark part within me that has sought that male validation for most of my life.
Any gardener knows that a flower that holds on to a bloom too long runs the risk of depleting resources for future blooms, and for the life of the plant in general. This is why we "dead-head" most flowers; but the blue flax, in the wisdom of the great Gardener, drops its blooms on its own, every day. It continually lets go in order to conserve strength, in order for the entire plant to become stronger, bigger, healthier. As I work to grow stronger, I think of all the petals that have littered the past 30 years, and I realize that I had to go through what I did in order to know what I know now. To have learned what I know about narcissism, about emotional abuse, and about how my conditioning made me susceptible back when I was 34 might have destroyed me; my roots weren't deep enough, my strength wasn't developed enough. And as I learn, let go, and connect to the voice within, it sounds a lot like the one I heard in that bar years ago: "Just go home, Darcy." Only now, that voice comes from a deeper place, a safer place; it sounds more like love and less like correction. Only now, I know my home is the wild soul within me, the force that blooms like the blue flax in the barrow ditches, for its own sake and nobody else's. Only now, I dance alone, wild and messy and uncertain, but finally free.